4 August 201621 September 2016 Reviews August in nonfiction Sarah Burnside Dark Money: How a Secretive Group of Billionaires is Trying to Buy Political Control in the US – Jane Mayer (Scribe) If you are searching for a relaxing read, I’d advise against picking up Jane Mayer’s excellent Dark Money, a frankly enraging account of the buying of political influence in the United States. The book’s subjects are united by their great wealth, their hostility to taxation and government regulation, and their determination to prevent elected officials from implementing policies not to their liking. (I did, however, develop some sympathy for the notorious Koch brothers on learning that at one stage they had a governess, ‘a fervent Nazi sympathiser’, who ‘enforced a rigid toilet-training regimen requiring the boys to produce morning bowel movements precisely on schedule or be force-fed castor oil and subjected to enemas’). Mayer, a New Yorker staff writer, lays out an impressive array of facts, carefully setting out the role of tax-exempt right-wing think tanks and the breadth of their influence. For instance, the conservative Olin Foundation ‘bankrolled a new approach to jurisprudence known as Law and Economics’, taught in elite universities, as well as funding all-expenses-paid seminars for judges: ‘a cross between Maoist cultural re-education camps and Club Med’. Alongside the book’s grand narrative we also find stories of individuals and families hurt along the way; people like Donald Carson, who developed leukaemia after being exposed to toxic substances at the Koch Refining Company and died having been refused workers’ compensation. However, the tone throughout is measured. Mayer lets the facts speak for themselves – and these ones shout. Thicker than Water: A Memoir of Family, Secrets, Guilt and History – Cal Flyn (HarperCollins) Uncomfortable facts of another kind form the subject matter of Thicker than Water by Scottish journalist Cal Flyn. The book documents Flyn’s attempts to come to terms with the fact that her great-great-great uncle Angus McMillan – remembered as a great pioneer and pious Christian – led several massacres of Aboriginal people in Gippsland in the 1840s. As Flyn decamps to Victoria and retraces her relative’s steps, a story unfolds of victims who were also victimisers: Scottish migrants who suffered the effects of the Highland Clearances and went on to brutally dispossess and murder another group of inconveniently placed landholders (it’s a story that Don Watson explored in his excellent 1984 book Caledonia Australis). At times I was impatient to move from Flyn’s beautifully written personal reflections back to her story’s dark heart, and she stumbles in a few places on the nuances of present day Australia; it’s rather optimistic to conclude that ‘[s]trict laws … protect and conserve archaeological sites’, for instance. However, her insights are sharp and her questions unsettling. At one point she asks Steve Paton, a young Gunai artist who accompanies her on her journey, about race relations: ‘Are there still two cultures, running alongside each other in parallel? Is one still in the process of being choked off by the other?’ Answers to eternal questions about man’s inhumanity to man remain elusive, but the simple truths burn: ‘The Highlanders were driven by rage and retribution. Their hearts were hardened by anger and grief. But oh … They must have known that this was wrong.’ Giving the Country a Memory: Contemporary Aboriginal Voices of Australia – Anne Brewster (Cambria) Turning to the present, Giving the Country a Memory features interviews with writers Kim Scott, Romaine Moreton, Jeanine Leane, Melissa Lucashenko (whose Meanjin essay on Indigenous polities is a must-read), Marie Munkara, Alf Taylor and the late Doris Pilkington about their work and their lives. This is a scholarly work, and some of Brewster’s reflections are rather densely written, but her interviews are nimble and the resulting conversations are a joy to read: by turns humorous and heart-wrenching, and always thoughtful, incisive and generous. Inevitably, the interviewees’ discussions of their life stories serve as indictments against successive policies of the settler state; as Marie Munkara comments, when an Indigenous person is born they ‘become political … it’s something that’s foisted on you’. The unbearable pain experienced by members of the Stolen Generations and their families is a constant presence in the book. There is also strength and resilience, though. Jeanine Leane observes that her use of humour ‘allows me to tell about these acts [sexual exploitation] – which were unfair and brutal – but it shifts Aboriginal people away from victimhood … ultimately they were survivors.’ First Bite: How We Learn to Eat – Bee Wilson (HarperCollins) There are many layers to First Bite, in which food writer and historian Bee Wilson navigates the guilt-ridden zone of not only how we eat, but how we feed our children. There are stories here from the author’s own life, as she learned to have a healthier relationship with food; there is discussion of the complexity of hunger, the treatment of child malnutrition, difficulties experienced by sufferers of anosmia, the variety of eating disorders and the damage they wreak, the futility of much dietary advice, the gendered way in which food is conceptualised, served and consumed, and the function of memory and nostalgia. Wilson’s focus is the affluent, calorie-soaked west, and her central argument is that food preferences are learned, not innate: they can therefore be unlearned. The chapter on the history and present state of ‘children’s food’ was particularly interesting, taking us from the ‘rice pudding debates’ of 1912–1913 to an age when ‘like medieval gingerbread, chicken nuggets [assume] many forms: dinosaurs, giraffes, spaceships’. First Bite was enjoyable and compulsively readable. Demonstrating my own lack of self-control, I binge-read it over a weekend. Wasted: A Story of Alcohol, Grief and Death in Brisbane – Elspeth Muir (Text) Dreadful sadness pervades Elspeth Muir’s Wasted. This is the story of Muir’s younger brother, who drowned while drunk at the age of twenty one, and the author has hammered out her pain into prose with an extraordinary precision. Wasted is also a tale of the part alcohol has played in Muir’s own life and in the lives of other Australians; from schoolies week to convivial binge-drinking to alcohol’s dark presence in sexual assaults and violent deaths. The discussion of the function of drinking in adolescence and young adulthood – a time of Passion Pop and bravado and cheap wine mixed with cordial – rings very true: ‘I don’t know why it was so important that there was alcohol, always. To go without just seemed not to be an option.’ Muir chronicles some of the problems caused by excess alcohol consumption and the piecemeal ways these are addressed by governments, which have in the main opted to target ‘minors, drink drivers and Indigenous people’ rather than taking a more holistic approach. The sections of the book which consider policies and cultural attitudes are strong, and the book could have done with more such analysis to complement the string of stories Muir tells from her life. Overall, though, this is a thoughtful, heartbreaking work. A Long Time Coming: Essays on Old Age – Melanie Joosten (Scribe) Melanie Joosten’s A Long Time Coming: Essays on Old Age examines issues including elder abuse, poverty and housing insecurity, loneliness, dementia, and the sheer invisibility of older people (especially women – there is a story here of a woman who painted ‘a splodge of colour’ in her hair so that people would notice her and found that she then ‘existed in the world again’). This heavy subject matter does not weigh down Joosten’s luminous essays, and several shine particularly brightly: ‘Notes on Writing and Doing Good’ sharply undercuts the wearingly familiar ‘why I write’ question with a discussion of the importance of care work, and ‘As Long as Life Endures’ is quietly, tremendously moving. Although Joosten examines specific difficulties faced by older people, she never loses sight of the broader political context. We live in an individualistic society in which the greatest value is accorded to people deemed economically productive: this is a problem for all of us, not only the elderly (a category into which most of us will eventually fall in any event). Joosten writes: ‘The myth of independence is the most harmful story we tell ourselves. None of us begin life alone, nor should we end it that way. The valuing of independence above the more accurate notion of interdependence restricts the possibilities allowed us’. This elegant plea for an expansion in the realm of the possible is a book to savour. – If you liked this article, please subscribe or donate. Sarah Burnside Sarah Burnside lives in Perth and writes about history, politics, policy and culture. She tweets at @saraheburnside More by Sarah Burnside Overland is a not-for-profit magazine with a proud history of supporting writers, and publishing ideas and voices often excluded from other places. If you like this piece, or support Overland’s work in general, please subscribe or donate. Related articles & Essays First published in Overland Issue 228 27 February 2023 Reviews Freeing the arts from the markets: a reading of Chokepoint Capitalism Lizzie O'Shea On one read, chokepoint capitalism is really just plain old capitalism. The regulatory barriers (or moats) that companies erect to protect their monopolistic/monopsonistic power—including regulatory capture, neutering of competitors, complex contractual terms with suppliers, and straight up non-compliance with their legal obligations—are how capital works to protect and reproduce itself. 8 First published in Overland Issue 228 1 February 20233 February 2023 Reviews This is where the rat bastard poem comes in Dan Hogan Rats will be found wherever nonsense presented as sense becomes the authority. Such is the cornerstone of anything organised along lines of capital: bureaucracies, workplace hierarchies, real estate, aspiration culture, institutions, ruling class artifice, governments, etcetera. Wherever there is capital there are rats—hoarding creatures, capital’s henchmen.