Cairo building, 1930s
Type
Article

The Cairo building, Fitzroy

There is a block of flats on Nicholson Street in Fitzroy called Cairo. Each cold grey day in Melbourne I pass the flats and wonder why they are named after an ancient, predominantly sunny city in the Middle East.

The apartment block, since heritage listed, was completed in 1936 by architect Best Overend as a functional and utilitarian abode for city workers. It’s now the setting for Chris Womersley’s new novel of the same name.

Overend labelled them ‘minimum flats’ after an article he published in a 1933 edition of Australian Home Beautiful. The block consists of 20 studios and eight one-bedroom apartments. The entry hall has a telephone and opens onto a timber-floored living space that includes seating space for two. There is a small kitchenette next to the entry hall.

At the time, the flats represented a new way of thinking about space. They were both economical and fashionable, something that was until then, relatively rare particularly in the bachelor pad, studio or bedsit market. The flats are considered iconic because of all this, and rightly so but what interests me, as a scholar of the Middle East, is the name. Why name such a residence, in all its stylish austerity, Cairo?

Edward Saïd’s foundational work Orientalism, published in 1978 (some forty years after the Cairo flats were built) explains part of the equation. In Saïd’s analysis, the West essentialises societies in the Middle East as static and underdeveloped. This crudity thereby fabricates an opinion of the Orient that can be studied, depicted, reproduced and most importantly, understood, by the implicitly developed, rational and superior West.

Between the World Wars, when Cairo was built, there was a cultural and political obsession with the mysterious east that has lasted in large part to the present day. While Britain, France and others were defining Middle Eastern national boundaries after the fall of the Ottoman Empire, art, fashion and culture developed a distinctly Nefertiti feel, while Art Deco buildings and Masonic temples of the period used stylised hieroglyphs as decorative motifs.

It remains the case that many of the prejudices and stereotypes about the Middle East or people of Arab and Islamic background are derived from this long tradition of banal imagery. Arabs are so often simplistically portrayed and understood as either oil suppliers, terrorists or belly dancers, and the Middle East itself as either an exotic or dangerous (or both) caricature of the real thing. Such stereotypes matter because they shape reporting and policy making towards the Middle East, and also have the power to influence communal understanding of the region.

It was almost certainly the case that Overend hoped some of the fashionable style associated with the Orient would permeate the flats if he named them after a prominent Middle Eastern city. But also the apartments were a revelation in their day and represented a new way of thinking about space, style and economy. While Overend made the private spaces smaller – each studio flat is 24m2 – he magnified the shared spaces, both functional and social, through the gardens, the communal dining area, the laundries and even the roof. There were flourishes in the use of finishes, including importing the design of curved aluminium door handles from London. The seemingly unsupported stairs were exotic, even unique, at the time of their design.

By using such design innovation, style and the creation of community could the architect be seen as dipping his hat to the modernism, advancement and innovation of such characteristics present in other cultures such as the Middle East?

Saïd talks about a lack of understanding of the ‘human density’ of the Orient. It seems that Overend’s creation of large gardens and communal dining spaces is a chance to do just that and perhaps an acknowledgement that human contact is an essential part of life. Perhaps the stylish and decorative finishes are not a way of reducing the region but of emphasising it.

So does all this mean we can never talk about the Middle East without being clichéd or reverential? I’m not sure. It seems difficult to reflect, write and research any foreign culture without bringing your own preconceptions and prejudices to bear. Perhaps some level of Orientalism is inherent in any analysis of the Middle East? The best we may be able to do is be aware of its existence and open our minds to other possibilities of lives both less and more ordinary than our own. Best Overend and Cairo have taught me that.

Overland is a not-for-profit magazine with a proud history of supporting writers, and publishing ideas and voices often excluded from other places.

If you like this piece, or support Overland’s work in general, please subscribe or donate.

Marika Sosnowski is a Middle East researcher and regular commentator on Melbourne radio station Triple R. She tweets at @mikisosnowski

More by

Comments

  1. Thanks Marika. I’ve often wondered where the name may have come from.

    With an ageing population, growth in 1 and 2 person households and housing unaffordability, the concept of smaller dwelling units with communal gardens like Cairo is as relevant today. Particularly close to public transport and urban amenity.

  2. In Womersley’s case, it appears that no, we can’t even “talk about the Middle East without being cliched or reverential”. Or at least, this is perhaps one explanation for a white-washed novel that not only skirts the issues you have raised here, but presents the most vanilla-scented depiction of inner-city Melbourne in the 1980s that ever went to print. Heterogenous, privileged twaddle that reads like a long form English assignment. Perhaps it only suffers by comparison; I watched ‘Pure Shit’ and re-read Peter Carey’s ‘The Fat Man in History’ in the same week.

    With so much fertile earth underneath (as you have turned up here), Cairo in print was smaller than the sum of its parts.

  3. Long time no see…I am currently reading Womersley’s Novel….
    “Cairo” has deep significance for me on two levels. Two of its previous tenants I knew. They were both homosexual men who lived there in the 60’s and late 80’s …The First was a colleague whom I met when teaching at Melbourne Grammar and although by 1976, he had left Cairo some years prior, when he took me in when I was homeless. The other, a Brit, whom I was introduced to, an activist with Homosexual Law Reform, sadly was found dead in his apartment in the 70’s. Many stories were shared of their days at Cairo ….Dad is still s Facebook and Instagram friend …Regards to Jordan and rest of the family
    Tis indeed One Degree of Aggravation
    Lloyd

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>