Published in Overland Issue Print Issue 199 Winter 2010 · Reviews / Main Posts Bendable Learnings: The Wisdom of Modern Management Tom Clark Don Watson Knopf ISBN 9781741669046, $32.95 Bendable Learnings reprises a theme that Don Watson established in 2003 with Death Sentence and continued in 2004 with Weasel Words. Over the intervening six years, he has tightened his aim to focus specifically on the managerial jargon that pervades all facets of institutional life. Like Weasel Words before it, this book remains in the shadow of Death Sentence, using new examples to fill out Watson’s existing themes. Each chapter lists a series of obtuse phrasings from a given field of endeavour: education (naturally), healthcare, public administration and so on. These gobbets have been provided by volunteers, Watson’s spies in the land of Mordor, who send the most egregious examples of management-speak they encounter. One of the main interests in reading this book, then, is to see whether any social enterprise in which one is a stakeholder has come in for adverse mention. I note that Victoria University (Overland’s chief backer, Watson’s erstwhile employer and my current employer) has drawn only light fire. Because he sought to write an interesting book about language that he characterises as boring, Watson has styled the chapters as an ironic workbook, with each gobbet framed by a ‘learning’ in the manner of a self-help text. Additionally, there is a set of ‘exercises’ near the end of the book for recapitulation of these learnings. The pseudo-pedagogical layout reveals two deeper facets of Watson’s project. One is his evident love for what he hates. Managerialism is entertaining, and not only as the butt of ridicule. There is an aesthetics to this ‘anaesthetic’ language, a beauty that has demonstrably entranced its leading critic. This tenderness interferes with Watson’s underlying pedagogy, based on a view he credits to Orwell about the relationship between clear expression and clear thinking. There are also strong echoes of Leavis in his moralising approach to public discourse. A less honest critic than Watson would conceal this tenderness, but I am glad he does not. It is the closest his analysis comes to taking these ‘learnings’ on their own terms. They are the poetry of institutional life. Tom Clark Tom Clark is a senior lecturer at Victoria University, and is president of the Australasian Universities Language and Literature Association. He is the author of Stay on Message: Poetry and Truthfulness in Political Speech (Australian Scholarly Publishing, 2012). More by Tom Clark › Overland is a not-for-profit magazine with a proud history of supporting writers, and publishing ideas and voices often excluded from other places. If you like this piece, or support Overland’s work in general, please subscribe or donate. Related articles & Essays 8 April 20249 April 2024 · Reviews Settlers or workers? Jordan Humphreys’ Indigenous Liberation & Socialism Jon Piccini In Indigenous Liberation & Socialism, historian and activist Jordan Humphreys probes the Australian far left’s evolving attitude towards Indigenous peoples, locating a tradition of working-class solidarity dating back to the 1890s. Humphreys is not blind, however, to the fact that this tradition was a minority perspective, or that solidarity was often clouded by paternalism and assimilatory thinking. 28 March 20249 April 2024 · Main Posts Why we should value not only lived experience, but also lived expertise Sukhmani Khorana In the wake of this year’s International Day for the Elimination of Racial Discrimination, I want to extend the central idea of El Gibbs’s 2022 essay on 'lived expertise' and argue that in media accounts of racism, analytical expertise and lived experience ought to be valued together and even in the same body.
