Blog

‹
›

‘So what are the differences between Tunisia and Egypt?’

Written by on 28-01-2011

For those following events in Egypt, this al-Jazeera interview with the US State Department’s PJ Crowley is essential viewing. I’ve taken the liberty of transcribing some of the highlights:

AJ: ‘But we’re not talking in general terms here. Egypt is not letting its people protest peacefully. It’s deploying the full ranks of its US-backed $1.3 billion backed security forces to beat up those protesters.’

US State Dept: ‘Absolutely. We want to see restraint on both sides.’

AJ: ‘So what specifically are you asking? A transition to democracy, a dismantling of the secret police, an end to torture, a national unity government? Because these are the things the protestors are asking for.’

Watch.

9 Responses to “‘So what are the differences between Tunisia and Egypt?’”

  1. clare says:
    January 28 2011 at 10:29 am

    ‘…and stop torturing people while you’re at it.’ Brilliant. Thanks Jack – a very revealing interview.

    Reply
  2. Tweets that mention ‘So what are the differences between Tunisia and Egypt?’ « Overland literary journal -- Topsy.com says:
    January 28 2011 at 10:47 am

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Overland Journal, Overland Journal, Benjamin Solah, Clare J Strahan, SmallIndiePress and others. SmallIndiePress said: ‘So what are the differences between Tunisia and Egypt?’ http://bit.ly/dK0H2v #press [...]

    Reply
  3. jack says:
    January 28 2011 at 10:49 am

    ‘Tis, and Joe Biden repeated it verbatim in his PBS interview:

    Asked if he would characterize Mubarak as a dictator Biden responded: “Mubarak has been an ally of ours in a number of things. And he’s been very responsible on, relative to geopolitical interest in the region, the Middle East peace efforts; the actions Egypt has taken relative to normalizing relationship with – with Israel. … I would not refer to him as a dictator.”

    [...]
    Biden urged non-violence from both protesters and the government and said: “We’re encouraging the protesters to – as they assemble, do it peacefully. And we’re encouraging the government to act responsibly and – and to try to engage in a discussion as to what the legitimate claims being made are, if they are, and try to work them out.” He also said: “I think that what we should continue to do is to encourage reasonable… accommodation and discussion to try to resolve peacefully and amicably the concerns and claims made by those who have taken to the street. And those that are legitimate should be responded to because the economic well-being and the stability of Egypt rests upon that middle class buying into the future of Egypt.”

    Egypt’s protesters, if they’re paying attention to Biden at all, will certainly be wondering which of their demands thus far have been illegitimate.

    Reply
  4. Jeff Sparrow says:
    January 28 2011 at 10:51 am

    ‘Hundreds are being detained. Perhaps we should be emphasising that more than Twitter and Facebook.’

    Reply
  5. Michael says:
    January 28 2011 at 1:59 pm

    More and more obnoxious.

    What about rubber bullets being fired at protestors? “We want to see restraint on both sides”

    Reply
  6. Michael says:
    January 28 2011 at 2:02 pm

    Crowley: Egypt should allow its citizens to protest peacefully
    AJ: If it doesn’t, will your funding to the Egyptian forces be in jeopardy?
    Crowley: Well I don’t see this as an either or proposition. *raves about how wonderful Egypt’s government is*.

    AJ: What are you calling for? An end to secret police? An end to torture? (etc) Because that’s what the protestors are calling for.
    Crowley: Again, there’s a fascinating process in the Middle East…

    Reply
    • Joshua Mostafa says:
      February 1 2011 at 9:46 am

      The state department official was playing the usual politician’s trick: asking the questions he would like to be asked – thus the nonsense about ‘taking a cookie cutter approach’ to the region – rather than answering the specific questions, e.g. about the huge US aid programme for the repressive security forces.

      Reply
  7. Aaron says:
    January 28 2011 at 2:16 pm

    Meanwhile the Australian Government has (that I’m aware) maintained total silence on the issue of the repressive measure being used by Mubarak’s forces to maintain his dictatorial machine including cutting the internet/SMS and killing protestors.
    Aligning ourselves with tyranny (as we surely have via our US/Israel/Egypt alliances) makes Australia a less safe place in the world – and it undermines our moral voice in the arena of diplomacy.

    Reply

Leave a reply